What you pay, it seems, is is the look. Honest layers come in a variety of prints, with some being limited edition or only available seasonally. This made them by far the most visually interesting to look at of all the diapers I've tested. But how important will it be when you roll it up (often filled with poo) and throw it in the trash? These layers were also the tightest of the bunch. The contoured rear clung to my daughter's butt with little sagging or swelling. But thisThis form could come at a price. My daughter had a three-way rash (in her back and both holes in the legs) in an Honest diaper - by far the messiest incident on the test - and I suspect it may have something to do with it poo that has nowhere to go.
The Honest Company likes to showcase its green credentials in its marketing, but some of the green attributes it touts are questionable. An example is the outer layer of "plant-based" polylactic acid, which can come from plants but is still a plastic that will not degrade for hundreds of years. At 43 cents per diaper in size 4, Honest is overpriced and not much better (if at all) than any other diaper on this list. $ 26 on Amazon
Alex Nishimoto / CNET
Founded in 1961, Pampers has been a major player in the disposable diaper game for 60 years. Chances are your parents, and maybe even their parents, wore Pampers. Being a household name ever since so long gives the brand a huge edge in the market, and for the most part, Pampers' reputation is earned by providing reasonable quality at an affordable price.
Thes Pampers performed well in testing. The elastic band creates a tight seal at the waist while providing a lot of comfort. The Velcro tabs easily separate from the back flaps and are a teal color, a feature my visually impaired stepdad liked because it made them easier to see compared to white on white. The leg holes fit my daughter's thighs a bit, but I didn't have any leaks. The diaper held up all night, although it left her skin damp in the morning despite these testers belonging to the Pampers Baby Dry range.
The Pampers work great for the price (32 cents each in size 4 ), but I just can't get past their baby powder smell. The scent is "non-allergenic and non-irritating to the skin," according to Pampers, but it's a little too strong for me. The Pampers Pure line is fragrance free, although more expensive at 33-60 cents per coat. About the ingredients, Pampers s ays it uses elemental chlorine free plush paste that is sourced from Sustainable Forestry Initiative certified sources. $ 27 on Amazon
Alex Nishimoto / CNET
These diapers have a lot in common with Pampers - and it's not acoincidence. Luvs and Pampers are both owned by Procter & Gamble, the former being the budget brand. But looking side-by-side at a Luvs and a Pampers Baby Dry, it's hard to tell where they cut costs.
The waistband is virtually identical to the Pampers, having the same stretchy back flaps with ease. - detachable fixing brackets. As you might expect, this means the fit is about the same i.e. very good. Even a peek under the topsheet with an X-Acto knife revealed no clear difference to my untrained eyes. Both appeared to have the same amount of fluffy pulp and three rows of super absorbent polymer gel. I haven't sampled the Pampers Swaddlers or Cruisers ranges so I can't say if they are similar as well.
A difference that places Pampers lovers in my book: lovers don 't have perfume! I also appreciateIt's not the brand's most streamlined lineup - there's a Lu vs Diaper and that's it. However, I can see how it could be a downside if the Luvs aren't a good fit for your baby. But if they do, you will save a considerable amount of money compared to Pampers, as each diaper costs only 12-24 cents. $ 30 on Amazon
Kirkland "Signature (Costco)
Alex Nishimoto / CNET
Because Costco heavily reduces the products it sells under its Kirkland Signature brand, the identity of Kirkland manufacturers is often kept under wraps. protect them from the dilution of their other, more expensive brands. Kirkland Signature diapers are said to be made by Kimberly-Clark, the personal care giant behind Huggies diapers.
Looking at the two side by side, it's easy to spot some similarities. Both have stretchy elastic belts and long attachment tabs filled with Velcro hooks. The Kirkland also has a pocket for catching poo, a signature Huggies feature. On my baby they fit pretty much like the Huggies I'm used to. However, I have noticed that the Kirklands tend to be wetter after anight of use, emitting a strong urine odor through my daughter's pajamas and occasionally being wet on the outside of the diaper. They didn't necessarily leak, but they didn't hold up as well as the others in the test.
The cost savings could come from an absorbent core less robust, although we can only speculate. But with the savings you will make by switching to Kirkland, you might be ready to accept this. Kirkland Signature diapers range from 17 to 33 cents per diaper, depending on size. But like most things at Costco, you have to buy in bulk to get that price (while still being a member). A size 4 box contained 198 diapers and was large enough for my 3 year old to play hide and seek.
Costco doesn't make much of the durability of its diapers, but says at least 20% of the materials used are plant-based. 40 $ at Costco
Up "& Up (target)
Alex Nishimoto / CNET
Choosing a store brand over a brand can seem like a gamble. Will you essentially get the same for less money or will you get exactly what you pay for? at 10-25 cents perdiaper, Target's Up & Up brand has a product that works well. They performed their intended function fairly well in this test, but would they be worth it in the long run? This is hard to say for me.
This layer should not be confused with anything other than a budget option. Just by manipulating them back to back with the other diapers I've tested, they seem insignificant. The pattern, although colorful, looks simple and generic (mine had whales printed on it) and the outer layer is plasticized and cheap. But once I got past that, I found the Up & Ups to fit my baby well thanks to an elastic waistband with accordion flaps that are easy to tighten while still allowing her space to move. I had no leaks with these diapers, even though they smelled strongly of urine after an overnight change. My daughter 's skin was wet in the morning, but none of the diapers I haveI tested couldn 't keep it completely dry overnight.
They look good on him, but they're a little bloated. Perhaps as a result, the Up & Ups offered some of the best blankets in this test, keeping her butt tucked inside most of the time. They work, and if your primary goal is to save money, they will serve you well. However, it should be noted that the ingredient list is clear on green credentials. $ 4 to target
Alex Nishimoto / CNET
Seventh Generation has established itself as an environmentally conscious brand, praising the use of plant-based ingredients in its products and an emphasis on recycling.With a disposable diaper, there isn't much you can do today to make it less harmful to the environment, but Seventh Generation makes at least an effort.
The company claims that the fluffy pulp used in its diapers is sustainably harvested and is Forest Stewardship Council certified. Seventh Generation diapers are also certified 30% biobased by the United States Department of Agriculture, which means they are made with a speciala certain amount of materials of vegetable origin.
It's great to be made from natural ingredients, but how well do they manage a baby's natural bodily functions? About as good as the rest, it turns out. We did not encounter any leaks or blowouts in our testing and found the fit to be perfect. The waistband is stretchy and the leg holes fit snugly around my daughter's plump thighs. One downside is that there is no moisture indicator strip so you will only have to switch to touch unless you change your baby regularly anyway. Just like others on this list, nighttime use has pushed these diapers to their limit. Again, there were no leaks, but her skin was still damp and occasionally cold.
At 32-56 cents per coat, Seventh Generation will only be worth it if you believe in the company's green mission. . TheTruth is, you always use a disposable diaper at the end of the day, and no matter where the materials come from, it will always stay in a landfill where it won't break down for hundreds of years. The company is at least transparent "on the fact that its layers are not biodegradable . $ 26 on Amazon
How I ' tested
I tested each baby diaper on my daughter for two full days and nights. She spends an average of six diapers a day and poops quite regularly. As I mentioned above, we are a Huggies family. But it turns out that my daughter was ready to go up a size at the start of the test, so even though my wife and I had a lot of experienceience with the Size 3 Huggies, the Size 4 Huggies were completely new to us and we spent the same amount of time with them as the rest of the diapers on this list.
I rated each layer based on the following criteria:
- Material quality: How soft is it on my baby's bottom? Is it as soft on the outside or is it smooth and plasticized?
- Ease of use: Is it easy to open and secure the Velcro flaps at the front of the diaper? How easy is it to tell when my daughter is wet?
- Absorption: How dry does the diaper keep my baby, especially at night?
- Fit: Does it fit properly? Do the leg holes create a tight enough seal to prevent leaks or blowouts? Is the belt tight yet comfortable?
- Cost: How much would it be?economical to use a given layer? Is it worth it?
- Environmental impact: is it partly plant or sustainable? Is the company doing something to compensate for the waste generated by its diapers?
What is a comfortable diaper?
As I started this test, I thought the answer to this question would be clear. But just like the layers themselves, there are many layers to this question. For example, it is important to first understand what makes a baby uncomfortable when wearing a diaper. Once again, here is Carlos Richer from Diaper Testing International:
Richer goes on to explain that this phenomenon of liquid contact with the skin is evaluated by what is called the re-humidification test. In this test, a certain amount of synthetic urine (no water, as it is not a good analogue for urine due to the content of saline solution).ne of your pee) is poured into a diaper. Then pressure is applied to simulate the weight of a baby and a filter paper is placed on top to observe how wet or dry the surface is. This is different from the retention test, which measures the ability of the absorbent core to hold urine when placed in a centrifuge. The retention test gives you an idea of the overall capacity of the diaper and how long it may elapse between changes. The re-humidification test, on the other hand, gives you an idea of how dry the baby feels and how much urine comes in contact with their skin.
"When talking about comfort, the most important parameter you have is rewet, "says Richer. "And rewetting has a very unpleasant effect. There is a correlation between it. The higher it is, the more diaper rash you will have, because after a prolonged period of exposure to moisture you break the skin, whichmakes her prone to rashes and infections. "
So how can you avoid this The sad truth is that it 's quite difficult in the economic level. Diapers in this category are designed according to a pattern or recipe of ingredients, which is decided based on the ce price of the diaper. This gives manufacturers a certain amount of materials to work with, including the super absorbent polymer and ADL, or diaper acquisition dispenser, a special type of non-woven material that quickly channels urine into the core while providing a wicking effect that helps keep moisture away from the topsheet.
Ultimately, however, the diaper comes at a price and there isn't much you can do. The best way to stay comfortable and fight diaper rash is to change diapers regularly.
What makes a diaper green?
The diaper industry takesnotes changing attitudes when it comes to reducing waste, reducing our carbon footprint and responsibly sourcing renewable materials. Many companies claim to be environmentally friendly, but there is still a lot of work to be done. Currently, no disposable diaper is truly compostable or recyclable. Dyper "has a program where you can pay to send your fecal soccer balls to a commercial composting facility. However, this requires adding certain elements to the compost mixture to cancel the methane production and dilute the salinity of the layer kernels.
Richer thinks that one day soon we will see a lot less diapers being sent to landfill. Instead, we might see a mix of industrial aerobic composting and industrial recycling, with installations that can sterilize, shred and sort the components of the diapers for reuse. So convenient and energy efficient, it seems like a great alternative to sending thousands of tons of diapers to landfill.
The information in this article is for educational and educational purposes only. for information only and does not constitute medical or health advice. Always consult a physician or other qualified health care professional with any questions you may have about a health problem or health goals.